Skip to main content

Christian Colleges in Indiana

32 schools in Indiana. See our methodology.

The University of Notre Dame stands as Indiana's most selective Christian institution, accepting just 12.9% of applicants while delivering median earnings of $99,980 that far exceed the state's other faith-based options. This stark contrast defines Indiana's Christian college market, where 32 schools serve students with vastly different academic profiles and financial outcomes. Oakland City University offers the most affordable path at $12,820 net price, while Saint Mary's College commands $28,552, reflecting a $15,732 spread that mirrors the state's economic diversity. Indiana's manufacturing backbone, anchored by companies like Cummins and Eli Lilly, creates demand for graduates across disciplines from engineering to healthcare administration. The state's 21st Century Scholars program covers full tuition for income-eligible students, making these institutions more accessible than their sticker prices suggest. Graduation rates span from 29.9% at Calumet College of Saint Joseph to Notre Dame's strong 96.8%, indicating significant variation in student outcomes. Schools like Taylor University and Indiana Wesleyan demonstrate that smaller Christian colleges can achieve solid 76.6% and 66.3% graduation rates respectively, while maintaining acceptance rates above 70% that welcome students seeking faith-integrated education in Indiana's growing economy.
32
Schools
$21,251
Avg. Net Price
$55,150
Avg. Earnings
58.4%
Avg. Graduation Rate

Christian Colleges in Indiana

College listings
# School Affiliation Enrollment Net Price Graduation Rate
1 Roman Catholic 8,923 $27,823 96.8%
2 Wesleyan 5,808 $16,767 37.2%
3 General Baptist 470 $12,820 70.0%
4 Interdenominational 1,890 $24,327 76.6%
5 Wesleyan 1,927 $23,069 66.3%
6 United Brethren 1,016 $13,710 68.2%
7 United Methodist 1,477 $20,230 71.3%
8 Brethren Church 1,511 $18,406 69.9%
9 Church of God 1,070 $22,144 49.4%
10 Roman Catholic 1,399 $28,552 76.5%
11 Other (not classified) 58
12 Presbyterian Church (USA) 958 $21,826 63.6%
13 United Methodist 3,147 $18,748 55.8%
14 Roman Catholic 560 $20,739 29.9%
15 Lutheran Church in America 2,229 $21,583 67.0%
16 American Baptist 872 $22,762 63.4%
17 Roman Catholic 2,336 $23,594 60.9%
18 Friends 612 $24,516 67.9%
19 Roman Catholic 1,599 $20,361 60.7%
20 Church of Brethren 895 $19,268 44.8%
21 Mennonite Church 761 $15,725 60.5%
22 Roman Catholic 896 $43,465 52.3%
23 Missionary Church 1,069 $19,726 57.2%
24 Roman Catholic 533 $26,470 29.5%
25 Roman Catholic 217 $25,172
26 Interdenominational 155 $7,187 36.4%
27 Baptist 114 $13,539 28.6%
28 Church of Brethren
29 Mennonite Church
30 Roman Catholic
31 Lutheran Church - Missouri Synod
32 Christian Church (Disciples of Christ)

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes Notre Dame different from other Christian colleges in Indiana?

Notre Dame accepts only 12.9% of applicants compared to the 55-98% acceptance rates at most other Christian schools in the state. Its graduates earn a median of $99,980, nearly double the $52,000-59,000 range typical of other Indiana Christian colleges, reflecting its national research university status.

How affordable are Christian colleges in Indiana compared to other states?

Net prices range from $12,820 at Oakland City University to $28,552 at Saint Mary's College. Indiana's 21st Century Scholars program covers full tuition for eligible students, making these schools particularly accessible. Most fall between $16,000-24,000 after aid.

Where do graduates of Indiana Christian colleges typically find employment?

Many work for Indiana's major employers including Eli Lilly, Cummins, and healthcare systems statewide. Median earnings range from $43,283 to $99,980 depending on the institution. The state's manufacturing and pharmaceutical sectors actively recruit from these programs.

Is there significant variation in graduation rates among these schools?

Graduation rates span from 29.9% at Calumet College of Saint Joseph to 96.8% at Notre Dame, showing remarkable variation. Mid-tier schools like Taylor University (76.6%) and University of Evansville (71.3%) demonstrate solid completion rates around the national average.

What size schools can students choose from among Indiana's Christian colleges?

Enrollment varies dramatically from Horizon University's 58 students to Notre Dame's 8,923. Most schools enroll between 1,000-2,000 students, offering small class sizes while maintaining sufficient resources. Only 5 schools exceed 2,000 students.

How competitive is admission to Indiana's Christian colleges?

Acceptance rates range from Notre Dame's highly selective 12.9% to several schools accepting over 90% of applicants. Most Indiana Christian colleges accept 70-85% of students, making them accessible while still maintaining academic standards for faith-centered education.

Related

Christian Colleges Nationally All Colleges in Indiana Cheapest Programs in Indiana

See our methodology for details on rankings and data sources.